This seminar examined the opportunities for developing practical local policies and programs to support high-growth entrepreneurship. High-growth entrepreneurs, often known as ‘gazelles’, have been the focus of much public policy interest because of the contribution they make to employment and economic growth (for example). Thus, many governments are eager to find and support high-growth entrepreneurs.
I have written previously on my suspicions regarding the feasibility of choosing high-growth firms before they grow. Our discussions during this seminar underscored these concerns.
While many policy makers are eager to invest public funds to support high-growth enterprises because of the significant impact they promise, there is very little evidence such investments succeed. I have listed a few relevant studies below.
High levels of enterprise growth are more likely to be found in mature firms that refocus their effort towards growth, than in new start-ups. Thus, a common theme of the day was that more attention should be given to supporting growth in mature firms. However, in contrast ti the evidence, governments typically invest more in enterprise start-ups and often abandon their support for later stages of enterprise growth.
Furthermore, most high-growth firms are self-selecting: they choose to obtain support to improve their prospects for, and ability to, manage growth. This is an important policy lesson for may governments, who are advised to create better, more enabling and entrepreneurial business environments, and opportunities for growth-oriented firms to access support, rather than attempting to select beneficiaries through a quasi-objective process.
High rates of firm growth can also be anticipated in markets and sectors that are growing faster than others and oriented toward national and international markets.
The question of whether public policies and programs can speed up the growth process was discussed. It was broadly agreed that public policies and programs can’t speed up the growth process. Indeed, enterprise accelerator programs can quickly become enterprise incinerators! The objectives for government policies and programs should be to improve firm competitiveness and help entrepreneurs diagnose their operations and know where to go to for support when they need it. Mentor support and improved business and market networks have proved valuable in this regard.
More than getting out of the way, local governments have an important role to play in bring together key local actors. Governments need to become more responsive to the needs and opportunities facing their local business sector in general, without attempting to decide which ones are more worthy of public support than others.
Some useful studies:
Bos & Stam (2013): Gazelles, Industry Growth and Structural Change
Davila, Foster, He & Shimizu (2015) The rise and fall of startups: Creation and destruction of revenue and jobs by young companies
Hendrickson, Bucifal, Balaguer & Hansell (2015) The employment dynamics of Australian entrepreneurship
Henrekson & Johansson (2010) Gazelles as job creators: a survey and interpretation of the evidence